Talk:Scouting in Minnesota

From WikiProjectMed
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Historical council information to be folded in

  • Minnesota Cass Lake 1917 1918
  • Minnesota 285 Crow Wing County 1923 1928 ended 1928
  • Minnesota 291 New Prague 1921 1925 merged into Rice-Scott-Le Sueur Area 288 1925
  • Minnesota 288 Faribault 1921 1926 merged into Rice-Scott-Le Sueur Area 288 1926
  • Minnesota 292 Northfield 1916 1925 merged into Rice-Scott-Le Sueur Area 288 1925
  • Minnesota 288 Rice-Scott-Le Sueur Area 1926 1929 changed name to South Central Minnesota 288 1929
  • Minnesota 288 South Central Minnesota Area 1929 1946 disbanded to 295 and 299 1946
  • Minnesota 297 Stillwater 1921 1922 changed name to Stillwater and Baytown Townships 297 1922
  • Minnesota 297 Stillwater and Baytown Township 1922 1925 changed name to Saint Croix 297 1925
  • Minnesota 297 Saint Croix 1925 ended 1925
  • Minnesota 282 Albert Lea 1921 1926 changed name to Southern Minnesota Area 282 1926
  • Minnesota 283 Austin 1921 1929 changed name to Cedar Valley Area 283 1929
  • Minnesota 282 Southern Minnesota Area 1926 1937 merged into Cedar Valley Area 282 1937
  • Minnesota 283 Cedar Valley Area 1929 1937 merged into Cedar Valley Area 282 1937
  • Minnesota 282 Cedar Valley Area 1937 1969 merged into Twin Valley 284 1969
  • Minnesota 284 Minnesota Valley Area 1927 1969 merged into Twin Valley 284 1969
  • Minnesota 284 Twin Valley 1969
  • Minnesota 284 Chisholm 1921 1925 merged into George Washington 290 1925
  • Minnesota 290 Hibbing 1920 1925 merged into George Washington 290 1925
  • Minnesota 298 Virginia 1919 1925 changed name to Arrowhead 298 1925
  • Minnesota 298 Arrowhead 1925 1928 merged into Iron Range 298 1928
  • Minnesota 287 Eveleth 1922 1929 merged into Iron Range 298 1929
  • Minnesota 290 George Washington 1925 1929 changed name to Headwaters Area 290 1929
  • Minnesota 298 Iron Range 1928 1932 merged into Headwaters Area 290 1932
  • Minnesota 286 Duluth 1919 1936 changed name to North Star 286 1936
  • Wisconsin 634 Superior 1922 1936 changed name to Gitche Gumee 634 1936
  • Minnesota 286 North Star 1936 1959 merged into Lake Superior 286 1959
  • Wisconsin 634 Gitche Gumee 1936 1959 merged into Lake Superior 286 1959
  • Minnesota 286 Lake Superior 1959 1994 August 1 merged into Voyageurs Area 286 1994 August 1
  • Minnesota 290 Headwaters Area 1929 1994 August 1 merged into Voyageurs Area 286 1994 August 1
  • Minnesota 286 Voyageurs Area 1994 August 1 http://www.vac-bsa.org
  • Minnesota 289 Minneapolis 1915 1922 changed name to Hennepin County 289 1922
  • Minnesota 289 Hennepin County 1922 1928 changed name to Minneapolis Area 289 1928
  • Minnesota 289 Minneapolis Area 1928 1951 changed name to Viking 289 1951
  • Minnesota 289 Viking 1951
  • Minnesota 295 Saint Paul 1915 1924 changed name to Ramsey County 295 1924
  • Minnesota 295 Ramsey County 1925 1929 changed name to Saint Paul Area 295 1929
  • Minnesota 295 Saint Paul Area 1929 1955 changed name to Indianhead 295 1955
  • Minnesota 288 South Central Minnesota Area 1929 1946 1/2 merged into Indianhead 295 1946
  • Minnesota 295 Indianhead 1955 http://www.indianhead.org
  • Minnesota 296 Saint Cloud 1921 1926 Central Minnesota 296 1926
  • Minnesota 296 Central Minnesota 1926
  • Minnesota 299 Winona 1921 1925 changed name to Gamehaven 299 1925
  • Minnesota 288 South Central Minnesota Area 1929 1946 1/2 merged into Gamehaven 299 1946
  • Minnesota 293 Rochester 1921 1929 merged into Gamehaven 299 1929
  • Minnesota 299 Gamehaven 1925

Merges

Merge Indianhead Council in to Scouting in Minnesota

The following discussions are an archived debate. Please do not modify it.

Subsequent comments should be made in a new section.

  • Oppose as the geographic subdivision includes "much of western Wisconsin. Its name comes from the shape of the Wisconsin-Minnesota border, which is said to resemble that of the head of an Indian." Sulfur 04:06, 13 April 2006 (UTC)[reply]
Two issues-one, we do keep articles separate from the parent or root state if they are large and fact-filled (and by large I mean a good page or more). The Indianhead paragraph does not qualify in either sense, so here will be a good place for it to gestate into a good article, rather than a stub.
Next, _many_ Councils cross state boundaries, and we can't just make an exception because a council is in two states. Someone interested will seek the Council in both states. I will put a link at Scouting in Wisconsin to come back to this article. Chris 00:47, 12 May 2006 (UTC)[reply]

Merge Many Point Scout Camp

The following discussions are an archived debate. Please do not modify it.

Subsequent comments should be made in a new section.

  • Oppose let the article be and give it time to grow. --evrik (talk) 20:47, 27 March 2007 (UTC)[reply]
  • comment it fails notability-it is not a Treasure Island or a Brownsea. Chris 03:59, 2 April 2007 (UTC)[reply]
    • It passes the google test. --evrik (talk) 17:52, 3 April 2007 (UTC)[reply]
  • support --Gadget850 ( Ed) 13:49, 2 April 2007 (UTC)[reply]
  • support there is not enough notable history for the article to stand on its own -- Horus Kol Talk 00:28, 3 April 2007 (UTC)[reply]
  • Oppose leave it alone, give it some growth time. Merging will not solve the problem, just make the page look worse. Justinm1978 05:29, 10 April 2007 (UTC)[reply]
  • Comment I don't see a consensus to merge. --evrik (talk) 23:19, 15 April 2007 (UTC)[reply]
  • Oppose There remains a lot of information that could be added to make the Many Point article more useful and which would be out of place in a braoder article such as this. --BenFranske 19:40, 18 April 2007 (UTC)[reply]
    • Comment because of a lack of consensus we should keep. --evrik (talk) 14:08, 23 May 2007 (UTC)[reply]

see also section?

Should there really be links to scouting in various Canadian provinces in this article?--Eightkinarrows 03:03, 31 July 2007 (UTC)[reply]

Retrieved from "https://mdwiki.org/wiki/Talk:Scouting_in_Minnesota"