Talk:List of bridges of the Merritt Parkway

From WikiProjectMed
Jump to navigation Jump to search

error? fabrication?

For Silvermine River Bridge, an editor changed "Original 1938 bridge replaced
Not on NRHP
" to "Original 1938 bridge replaced
No longer on NRHP
", i.e. implying the bridge was once NRHP-listed and then was delisted. I see no evidence for that. I used an Elkman-supplied tool to search for NRHP listings, including properties that have been delisted, and do not find this item. Is the change introducing fabrication or what? I am getting P.O.'d with the particular editor adding stuff with no sources. Since the U.S. National Register was not started until 1965, while the bridge was demolished earlier according to a HAER record that I had uncovered and this editor pasted into this article, i believe it's just fabrication, reaching a false conclusion. doncram (talk) 06:27, 21 January 2010 (UTC)[reply]

The "no longer on NRHP" phrasing is indeed incorrect. This should be changed to "not on NRHP" as this is not listed as a contributing property. --Polaron | Talk 13:47, 21 January 2010 (UTC)[reply]